Signal No. 191 · Crimean Bridge: road span down

Signal No. 191 · Crimean Bridge: road span down

A road span of the Crimean Bridge falls after weeks of Ukrainian strikes on the air defences around it. The Pentagon’s policy chief tells EU defence ministers that Washington opposes shutting US firms out of Europe’s defence market.

Großwald profile image
by Großwald
SIGNAL No. 191
Crimean Bridge: road span down
A road span of the Crimean Bridge falls after weeks of Ukrainian strikes on the air defences around it. The Pentagon’s policy chief tells EU defence ministers that Washington opposes shutting US firms out of Europe’s defence market. Germany pays into another US Patriot package for Ukraine, and Britain pledges short-range missiles from Belfast. Germany signs for four more MEKO A-200 DEU frigates from TKMS. French trainers are reported to be working inside Ukraine, and Moscow calls that participation in the war. The Commission pays Ukraine another EUR 1.71 billion for weapons, Romania bills Rheinmetall for late air defence upgrades, Britain buys drones for its troops in Estonia, Bulgaria’s cabinet moves toward 57 CAESAR howitzers, and France selects Tekever’s AR5.

STKRUCDEZ A road span of the Crimean Bridge falls after weeks of Ukrainian strikes on the air defences around it

Kyiv Independent 17 Nov · Euronews 17 Nov · Ukrainska Pravda 17 Nov · Militarnyi 17 Nov, Destinus · Guardian 4 Mar 2024 · Signal No. 166 · Signal No. 174 · Signal No. 175 · Signal No. 177

One of the Crimean Bridge’s two arches and the road span beneath it fell into the Kerch Strait overnight into Tuesday, after Ukraine’s second strike in two days. Images on Russian and Ukrainian channels show the arch gone. The SBU security service said “one of the metal arches and the automobile span under it were completely destroyed”. Russia’s transport ministry suspended road and rail traffic, said the damage was being assessed and reported no casualties. It did not confirm a collapse. A first strike on Monday morning had restricted traffic. The 19-kilometre bridge is a main supply route for Russian forces in southern Ukraine. Strikes in October 2022 and July 2023 did not close it for long.

Volodymyr Zelenskyy called the strike the seventh phase of a weeks-long operation by the SBU and the General Staff using 11 weapon types. In it, he said, Ukrainian forces “systematically destroyed air defense systems, radars, electronic warfare assets, and other designated targets along the path to the final objective”. In the final stage, he said, Palianytsia missile-drones hit the road section, while Neptune missiles, Ruta drones and FP-5 Flamingos hit the railway section. He singled out a Flamingo precision strike. He did not say how many weapons were launched, how many hit, or which brought the span down. Destinus, which makes the Ruta, wrote on LinkedIn that its missiles hit the bridge on both days: they damaged the upper support structure overnight, then seven more struck and a span collapsed. Zelenskyy, however, put the Ruta on the railway section, and the span that fell carried the road. The chief engineer of Fire Point, the Flamingo’s maker, appeared to confirm its use.

Signal › In October Germany’s Army inspector argued for low-cost cruise missiles on range and mass: targets some 1,500 kilometres deep, enough missiles to saturate air defences. The span fell after weeks of strikes on the air defences, radars and jammers around it. Berlin has weighed two of the named weapons for its own forces. Fire Point’s Flamingo was one of three candidates in the ministry’s June planning, though not among the two that sources named in October. Destinus announced a Ruta line with Rheinmetall at Unterlüß and, Welt reported, has offered the ministry missiles matching later Ruta blocks with Helsing. Kyiv puts both on the railway section; the span that fell carried the road, which it says Palianytsia missile-drones hit. The strike says little about either missile. What it shows Berlin is the sequence: weeks of suppressing the defences around one target before the final strike, where the inspector’s case rests on numbers saturating them. Germany’s own estimate, from a 2024 Luftwaffe call Russia intercepted, was that 10 to 20 Taurus might bring the bridge down.

ATLDININT Colby tells EU defence ministers Washington strongly opposes excluding US firms from European defence markets

US Department of War 17 Nov, Colby remarks · Reuters 17 Nov (The Business Standard) · Defence24 17 Nov · Bird & Bird, SAFE Regulation · Signal No. 141 · Signal No. 175

Elbridge Colby, the Pentagon’s under secretary for policy, addressed EU defence ministers in Brussels on Tuesday. In remarks his department published as prepared, he said Washington is “more receptive to the EU in this arena than American governments have been in the past, provided the EU approach is non-exclusionary”. He added: “we strongly oppose measures to exclude American firms from competition in European markets”, and said the same applied to other non-EU NATO allies. The balance he proposed is “transatlantic joint ventures, licensed co-production, and co-development”, above all in air and missile defence, artillery and precision munitions. Poland, he said, had “set the standard” by pairing large American purchases with local industrial partnerships, and Germany was “producing PATRIOT missiles in Bavaria”. America’s own capacity, he said, depends on Congress funding the President’s defence budget: without adequate funding, “it will severely hamper our ability to meet not only our but particularly allied demand.”

He also took aim at a European fighter: “there is no way that a gathering of disparate so-called middle powers would ever be able to build a competitor to the F-35 in a timely fashion”, and the attempt would “almost certainly result in the waste of European and Canadian money”. Before the meeting Boris Pistorius said: “We expect changes in troop levels, but we don’t know anything concrete yet.” Reuters reports the result of the US force posture review for Europe is expected before Christmas. Colby told the Polish side the report reaches the White House in the first days of December. Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz, Poland’s defence minister, said the United States can count on Poland’s support in opening the European market to American industry and moving production from the United States to Europe. Poland also backs including non-EU allies such as Britain and Türkiye, he said.

Signal › The exclusion Colby objects to is already written into the EU’s defence money. SAFE’s EUR 150 billion in loans and the Ukraine Support Loan require at least 65 per cent of a product’s component cost to come from the EU, EEA-EFTA states or Ukraine. For air and missile defence, the area he put first, SAFE also requires that the prime contractor can change the design without third-country restrictions. A licence-built US interceptor therefore stays outside SAFE however many of its parts are made in Europe. In September the Ukraine loan needed a derogation to pay for PAC-3 rounds. His co-production offer does not meet that rule, so what he is asking for is a change to it. Poland, which holds SAFE’s largest allocation, says it backs opening the European market to American industry.

IAMDRUCDEZ Germany puts USD 300 million into a US Patriot package for Ukraine at the Contact Group in Brussels

Kyiv Independent 17 Nov · Ukrinform 17 Nov · Reuters 17 Nov (The Business Standard) · UK Ministry of Defence 17 Nov · Interfax-Ukraine 17 Nov, Sweden · US Department of War 17 Nov, Colby remarks · ioplus 8 Sep · Lockheed Martin 27 Oct · Signal No. 174 · Signal No. 185

Germany will put USD 300 million into PURL, NATO’s scheme for allies to buy American weapons for Ukraine, Boris Pistorius said in Brussels on Tuesday, sponsoring the package with Norway: “the focus is air defense, especially PAC-2 and PAC-3 Patriot missiles.” It is the fifth PURL package Germany has joined, and he gave the reason: “We are purchasing from the United States systems that are not available in Europe.” Germany will also send radars, drones and ammunition for the F-16s Ukraine uses against drones, and is preparing to integrate IRIS-T missiles into the NASAMS systems Norway supplies. Europe has “a very strong industrial base” that could build American systems or ammunition under licence if Washington agrees, he said, and he would raise it with Colby.

At the Contact Group, which Pistorius co-chairs with Wes Streeting, the British defence secretary, Britain committed GBP 240 million: more than 1,000 short-range air defence missiles and launchers from Thales in Belfast, delivered from mid-December, and more than a dozen radars. The missiles have proven effective against the jet-powered Shahed drones Russia now flies, the UK says. Sweden added SEK 720 million for multilateral funds, about SEK 200 million of it for PURL. Britain, Sweden and Ukraine signed a letter of intent committing in principle to provide Ukraine with Gripen fighters and a range of weapons for them; Saab signed a SEK 24.6 billion Gripen E contract for Ukraine on 30 June.

On 7 November Pistorius said Germany could give no more Patriot systems from Bundeswehr stocks for now, because anything given would not be replaced for the time being.

Signal › PURL buys from American stocks and production lines, so Washington sets the delivery order, and by Colby’s account to EU ministers, meeting allied demand depends on Congress funding the President’s budget. Pistorius’s reason, systems “not available in Europe”, holds fully for the PAC-3 MSE, the hit-to-kill round: Lockheed Martin builds it in the United States, and Europe has supply-chain work and a maintenance facility planned in Poland. For the PAC-2 it holds until COMLOG, the Raytheon and MBDA Deutschland venture at Schrobenhausen that Colby cited as “producing PATRIOT missiles in Bavaria”, delivers its first rounds, in 2027 at the earliest. Britain’s order is the European route, a Belfast line delivering from mid-December, and it covers the drones, not the ballistic missiles Patriot is bought for.

DEZSEADIN Germany signs for four more MEKO A-200 DEU frigates, taking TKMS’s order to eight anti-submarine ships

defence-network 17 Nov · hartpunkt 17 Nov · Signal No. 163

The BAAINBw, the Bundeswehr’s procurement office, and TKMS signed the contract for a second lot of four MEKO A-200 DEU frigates on Tuesday, exercising the option the Bundestag’s budget committee cleared in October. The navy’s order rises to eight identical ships for anti-submarine warfare, the class that replaces the F126 programme the ministry ended in June. The signing reports carry no contract value. In October the reported price was EUR 5.3 billion for the construction contract, with EUR 5.6 billion budgeted for ships five to eight including project support and a reserve. The first ship is to be handed over in December 2029 and the others at intervals of about nine months, according to the BAAINBw and TKMS. Sections of the first ship have been built since February and its keel was laid in May. Oliver Burkhard, TKMS’s chief executive, said the four option ships secure series production for the long term.

Signal › A nine-month interval from December 2029 puts the eighth ship in spring 2035, the completion date the finance ministry gave the budget committee in October. That is one building line delivering one ship after another. The committee’s July conditions asked the ministry to examine parallel production once the option was exercised, and asked TKMS to take on, where possible, the subcontractors and yards the F126 cancellation left without work, the option ships included. Both conditions now apply. A schedule that still ends in 2035 does not yet include a second line, which is what would bring the last ships forward.

OPSRUCDIP RFI reports French instructors inside Ukraine under a mission called Volia, and Moscow calls it direct participation in war

Kyiv Independent 16 Nov (RFI) · Euronews 17 Nov, Lavrov

Small groups of French military personnel have worked in Ukraine since at least the summer under a confidential mission called Volia, RFI reported on Monday, citing several sources. They deploy for short periods to train Ukrainian troops and maintain equipment France supplied, including the Caesar howitzer and the Mirage 2000. Their number was not disclosed. They travel through Gerfaut, the French detachment in Poland serving EUMAM, the EU’s training mission for Ukraine. A source told AFP that French instructors do rotate “in France, in Poland or, in some cases, directly in Ukraine”, but that “this is not a military operation. There is no intention of taking part in combat.” RFI says Parliament was not formally informed.

Sergei Lavrov, Russia’s foreign minister, said on Tuesday that foreign military personnel had been in Ukraine “for more than six months. And not only the French”, and that this was “no longer support for Ukraine but direct participation in the war, just like help with target designation, the supply of satellite data and much else.”

Signal › Article 35 of the French constitution obliges the government to inform Parliament of a decision to have the armed forces intervene abroad no later than three days after the intervention begins. If the intervention runs past four months, the government must seek Parliament’s authorisation. The AFP source describes rotations with no combat role and says they are not a military operation; that is not an intervention in the article’s sense. A mission running since the summer can therefore go unreported without breaching the text. The force the Coalition of the Willing plans for Ukraine would deploy after a ceasefire and would be an intervention on any reading, so Article 35’s three-day notice and four-month vote would apply. Lavrov’s list also includes targeting help and satellite data, which are provided from outside Ukraine; in his account, the size of the French footprint therefore changes little.

Procurement · Industry · Capability

INTRUCDIN Commission pays Ukraine another EUR 1.71 billion for drones, ammunition and air defence

The Commission made the eighth payment under the defence component of the EUR 90 billion Ukraine Support Loan on 16 November, for drones, ammunition and air defence systems including early-warning radars and missiles, bought from Ukrainian and European manufacturers. About 40 per cent of it funds contracts with manufacturers established in the EU. EUR 10.2 billion remains available under the loan’s defence-industrial strand for the rest of 2026.

European Commission 16 Nov

CEEIAMDDIN Romania sends Rheinmetall a first EUR 8.7 million penalty invoice over late air defence upgrades

Romania has imposed contractual penalties on Rheinmetall for late air defence deliveries, Defence Minister Ștefan-Radu Oprea said; the first invoice, for EUR 8.7 million, was reportedly issued on 8 November and covers part of the total. Rheinmetall told Romanian officials it expects to deliver equipment meeting the requirements in December, and Oprea said further penalties could follow if it falls short of the specifications. He did not name the contract; it appears to be the 2023 upgrade of Oerlikon GDF-003 guns to the Skynex standard, two batteries due by April 2026 and two by December. Romania’s SAFE-financed orders with Rheinmetall this year include Lynx vehicles and Skyranger 35, Skynex and Millennium systems.

defence-industry.eu 17 Nov

GRDUXS Britain buys hundreds more attack drones and counter-drone kit for its troops in Estonia

GBP 25 million from the Defence Investment Plan buys hundreds more one-way attack and first-person-view drones for British forces in Estonia, doubles the reconnaissance drones available to them and adds body-worn and vehicle-mounted electronic warfare equipment and shotguns against drones, the Ministry of Defence said.

UK Ministry of Defence 17 Nov

CEEGRD Bulgaria’s cabinet asks parliament to approve 57 CAESAR howitzers under SAFE

Bulgaria’s Council of Ministers on 16 November proposed that the National Assembly approve the investment project for 57 CAESAR 155 mm self-propelled howitzers with ammunition and support equipment, financed through SAFE, and authorised the defence minister to negotiate and sign orders with France. No contract has been signed.

Army Recognition 17 Nov

UXSC4I France selects Tekever’s AR5 for long-range army reconnaissance, a framework of about EUR 150 million

The DGA selected Tekever after a competition launched in spring under ADAPT, the programme for drones operating in depth, the armed forces ministry said on 16 November. The first requirement is five systems, with more possible to 2028; the framework, about EUR 150 million, is to be signed before the end of 2026. The AR5 covers part of the gap left by delays to the Patroller drone.

Army Recognition 17 Nov

Forward Look

This week. 18–19 November: the APEC summit in Shenzhen, where Yuri Ushakov, Putin’s foreign-policy aide, says Putin and Trump will meet (Kremlin 12 Nov). Thursday 19 November: the Coalition of the Willing meets in Berlin, where Britain’s prime minister is to set out the rest of its winter package (Ukrinform 3 Nov; UK Ministry of Defence 17 Nov). US envoys, Ukrainian officials and European allies are to meet in Berlin this week, possibly the same day, to coordinate negotiating positions (Kyiv Independent 17 Nov). The German army stands up eight battalions at Munster, among them the artillery and supply battalions of Panzerbrigade 45 (German Army 12 Nov); the Folketing’s final vote on the Greenland agreement (Ritzau 22 Oct). End of the week: Estonia’s government decides on closing its road crossings with Russia from 1 December (ERR 16 Nov).

Later. 24–27 November: the Bundestag’s second and third readings of the 2027 budget, with the Bundesrat on 18 December (defence-network 13 Nov). 26–27 November: the European Council on Ukraine’s financing for 2027 (European Commission 12 Nov) and Rheinmetall’s capital markets day (dpa-AFX 5 Nov). First days of December: the US Europe Posture Review reaches the White House, by Warsaw’s account (Defence24 17 Nov). 12 January: the Seimas’s final vote on deleting Article 137 (BNS via LRT 6 Oct).

Exercises. No changes since Monday. Full calendar: Großwald NATO Exercises 2026.

Großwald profile image
by Großwald

Subscribe to Signal.

Your daily briefing on procurement, force posture, industrial capacity and the alliance. Every weekday, 23:00 CET.

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More