Signal No. 192 · Pentagon faults Ukraine’s deep strikes, Berlin objects

Signal No. 192 · Pentagon faults Ukraine’s deep strikes, Berlin objects

The Pentagon’s policy chief says Kyiv’s deep strikes into Russia do not work; Pistorius calls the criticism stupid. The Commission proposes a EUR 45 billion loan for Ukraine in 2027. Poland confirms reinforcements near Kaliningrad, citing a real Russian threat.

Großwald profile image
by Großwald
SIGNAL No. 192
Pentagon faults Ukraine’s deep strikes, Berlin objects
The Pentagon’s policy chief says Kyiv’s deep strikes into Russia do not work; Pistorius calls the criticism stupid. The Commission proposes a EUR 45 billion loan for Ukraine in 2027. Poland confirms reinforcements near Kaliningrad, citing a real Russian threat. Crosetto tells Leonardo to think carefully before selling its Avio stake to ICEYE. Germany nears a deal for two missile-warning satellites. Also: the EU’s eight joint-project areas, Spexer radar production at ZF, MBDA’s orbital-strike study, an Irish spaceport study by OHB, more Mirages for Ukraine and the Orbiter 4 in Germany.

STKATLRUCDEZ The Pentagon’s policy chief tells Ukraine’s backers Kyiv’s deep strikes do not work, and Pistorius rejects the criticism

RFE/RL 17 Nov · Ukrainska Pravda 17 Nov · Anadolu 17 Nov · Stars and Stripes 18 Nov · dpa-AFX 18 Nov · Ukrinform 17 Nov, Khmara · General Staff 18 Nov · BMVg 28 May 2025 · 8 Jul 2026 · Ukrainska Pravda 9 Sep 2025 · Ukraine MoD 8 Jul 2026 · CNN 11 Oct · Interfax-Ukraine 13 Oct · Ukrinform 17 Nov · Ukrainska Pravda 16 Aug · Signal No. 191

Elbridge Colby, the Pentagon’s under secretary for policy, told the Ukraine Defense Contact Group in Brussels on Tuesday that Ukraine’s strikes deep inside Russia are not working. “Our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war,” he said, “nor do they contribute to blunting Russia’s advances on the front line.” Strikes on civilian infrastructure, “such as Wildberries”, “have actually probably hardened the Russian public’s resolve and the Kremlin’s own willingness to escalate”. Kyiv says the online retailer’s warehouses supply drone and military components; in August Ukraine’s defence ministry said strikes had disabled seven of Wildberries’ ten largest logistics centres.

He drew a line: Ukraine “should not be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back”, but “the focus of our support should be on enabling and advancing Ukraine’s ability to hold the line of battle”. Strikes on the front line and in direct support of the battle area fall within that focus, he said, and the mid-range strike campaign has been “very effective”. He did not name the Crimean Bridge, which Ukraine struck overnight into Tuesday for the second time in two days; the SBU said an arch and the road span beneath it were destroyed. Diplomats cited by dpa think his remarks were likely linked to that strike. “The balance of advantage in deep strikes may well favour Moscow,” he said. Russia, he said, will keep generating manpower and mobilising its war economy “for the long haul”.

Asked about Colby’s remarks after the meeting, Boris Pistorius said that “criticizing strikes like that in Russia to destroy strategic military and military-used targets is quite a stupid thing, I think”. Russia’s nightly strikes on Ukraine’s energy, water and heating were “kind of terrorism”, he said, and “we should rather talk about that than about legal and legitimate strikes in Russia against non-civilian targets.” Wes Streeting, the British defence secretary, said it is “not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war”, and that the strikes had “helped to degrade Putin’s war machine, buying time and saving lives”.

Yevhenii Khmara, Ukraine’s defence minister, said at the same press conference: “As for long-range strikes, we consider this a promising area and plan to triple these capabilities next year.” Ukraine will have more jet-powered drones, he said. Volodymyr Zelenskyy wrote that Ukraine had responded to Russian attacks and would keep doing so. The General Staff said it struck the Ilsky and Afipsky refineries in Krasnodar Krai from the air on Tuesday and overnight into Wednesday.

Germany pays for part of that capacity. In May 2025 Germany’s defence ministry said Germany would finance the production of long-range weapon systems in Ukraine; in September 2025 Pistorius put contracts for several thousand Ukrainian long-range drones at EUR 300 million, and in July 2026 Berlin signed an agreement to produce Ukrainian deep-strike drones in Germany (Bars missiles, by Kyiv’s account). In October two European officials told CNN that the State Department and the Pentagon had warned the US could suspend intelligence sharing and European PURL purchases if strikes on Russian energy continued; Trump answered “No, we haven’t” when asked whether the US had cut intelligence sharing. On Tuesday Germany and Norway each put another USD 300 million into PURL, for Patriot rounds that reach Ukraine only when the Pentagon releases them.

Signal › European money buys Ukrainian-built long-range drones that no US release governs. Washington’s leverage over the campaign Colby criticised runs through the two channels it threatened in October, by CNN’s account: intelligence sharing, and the PURL purchases whose Patriot rounds reach Ukraine only when the Pentagon releases them. Of the two, only intelligence bears directly on the strike campaign. Withholding the rounds would punish the campaign by weakening Ukraine’s defence against the Russian strikes Pistorius called terrorism.

INTRUCDPL The Commission proposes a EUR 45 billion loan for Ukraine in 2027, up to EUR 25 billion of it military

European Commission 18 Nov · Ukrinform 18 Nov · Kyiv Post 16 Nov (Financial Times) · EUbusiness 18 Nov · Federal Government 10 Nov · dpa 10 Nov · Agence Europe 5 Feb · 17 Nov · European Parliament via EEAS 23 Jan

On Wednesday the Commission proposed a new loan of up to EUR 45 billion for Ukraine in 2027, financed by EU borrowing and guaranteed by the headroom in the EU budget: up to EUR 25 billion for military assistance and up to EUR 20 billion in budget support tied to reforms, the rule of law and anti-corruption among them. Ukraine would repay the principal only once it receives reparations from Russia, and the Commission proposes that future windfall profits from immobilised Russian assets could help repay both this loan and the EUR 90 billion one. The remaining EUR 45 billion of the EUR 90 billion Ukraine Support Loan will be disbursed in 2027. On top of that, the new loan would cover two thirds of what the Commission calls Ukraine’s additional financing needs for next year, put at EUR 70 billion; the remaining third has to come from other partners.

“For 2026, Ukraine’s needs are covered,” Ursula von der Leyen said. The package would amend the regulation on the EU’s multiannual budget so that the budget can guarantee the loan. The proposals go to the Parliament and the Council, and she will present them to the European Council next week.

The EUR 90 billion loan ran through enhanced cooperation because Czechia, Hungary and Slovakia opted out of backing it. On Monday the Financial Times reported, citing four people familiar with the plan, that Bulgaria has joined them in signalling it will not contribute to further financing for Ukraine. Friedrich Merz, standing beside Hungary’s prime minister Péter Magyar on 10 November, called further financing for Ukraine “a task for all of us”, and von der Leyen backs his call for every member state to take part. He has tied the talks on the EU’s next seven-year budget to the same question: without “significant changes” in António Costa’s proposals, he said, “it will not be possible to conclude negotiations any time soon”.

Signal › The loan can again run among the willing; its guarantee cannot. The budget headroom backs the borrowing only through the amendment to the multiannual budget regulation, which the Council adopts unanimously under Article 312 of the TFEU. For the EUR 90 billion, Czechia, Hungary and Slovakia let that amendment pass on terms that left them without financial obligations from the loan, and the other 24 carry its interest, close to EUR 3 billion a year. Interest is the cost that recurs whether or not Russia ever pays. Who pays it on the new loan is still under discussion, Agence Europe reports. Exempting the four that, by the FT’s account, have signalled they will not contribute would move that bill onto the rest, which is what Merz’s “task for all of us” argues against. The next seven-year budget needs unanimity too, so every government holds a veto in both negotiations, Berlin included.

PLBGRZ Poland’s minister for the special services confirms a deployment near Kaliningrad against what he calls a real Russian threat

Defence24 18 Nov (Rzeczpospolita) · Militarnyi 18 Nov · Signal No. 149

In late October Poland sent police and Border Guard reinforcements and more ABW counter-intelligence officers to Warmia-Masuria, on the border with Russia’s Kaliningrad region, and teams of the GROM, NIL and AGAT special-forces units exercised there. The aim was to stop a Russian provocation that, according to Rzeczpospolita’s security-service sources, was meant to cause mass casualties and put the blame on Ukraine. The plan, the paper reported, could have included people crossing the border and a staged attack on a facility on the Russian side “under a foreign flag”, with the aim of stopping Polish aid to Kyiv; one source compared it to the Gleiwitz incident of 1939. The warning came from foreign intelligence services, the paper reported, and Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia received similar warnings; Ukraine’s foreign intelligence service warned in mid-October of a provocation on NATO’s eastern flank.

Tomasz Siemoniak, the minister coordinating the special services, confirmed that the measures had been taken in recent weeks: “we judged there was a real threat.” Asked whether Russia planned mass casualties, he said he did not know; that was a question for the Russians. That the public knew of the deployment was part of the deterrence, he said. No arrests have been reported. In September, after Russian strikes near Poland’s border with Ukraine, Lithuania’s foreign minister said Vilnius had discussed “a potential false-flag operation by Russia”.

Signal › The plot and its corroboration come from one side. Rzeczpospolita’s sources sit in the security services Siemoniak coordinates, and the warnings to Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia reach the record through the same paper, so the minister’s confirmation of the measures and the paper’s account of the plot do not corroborate each other; the plot itself he did not confirm. The one public warning from outside Poland is Ukraine’s foreign-intelligence warning in mid-October, and it is broader: a provocation on NATO’s eastern flank.

SPCDIN Crosetto tells Leonardo to think carefully before selling its Avio stake into ICEYE’s EUR 2 billion bid

Teleborsa 18 Nov · hartpunkt 17 Nov · askanews 17 Nov · BusinessPeople 18 Nov · Milano Finanza 17 Nov · 18 Nov · Avio 11 Nov · Defense News 17 Nov · ICEYE offer notice 17 Nov · Leonardo governance report 11 Mar 2026 · Civil Code art. 2368

Guido Crosetto, Italy’s defence minister, told Reuters on Wednesday: “If I were Leonardo, I would think carefully before exiting Avio.” On Tuesday ICEYE, the Finnish maker of radar-imaging satellites, offered EUR 41 a share in cash for all of Avio, about EUR 2.05 billion, and aims to delist it. By ICEYE’s figure, the price is a premium of 21.3 per cent on Monday’s close. Avio, not to be confused with GE’s Avio Aero, builds the Vega launcher and solid-propellant rocket motors and supplies missile propulsion to MBDA. In September it broke ground in Hurt, Virginia, on a US plant for solid rocket motors for tactical missiles, where Lockheed Martin plans to have motors for its extended-range GMLRS and PrSM built once they are qualified.

ICEYE says it wants to build a vertically integrated European space and defence company, pledges EUR 1 billion of investment in Italy over five years after closing and says Italy would remain the centre of launch and propulsion. Leonardo is the largest shareholder with 18.04 per cent. Its chief executive, Lorenzo Mariani, called the bid “a good sign” and the stake strategic for launch capacity and for the propulsion Avio supplies to MBDA, and said any decision would be coordinated with the government.

The offer needs at least 66.67 per cent of the capital, clearance under Italy’s golden-power rules, foreign-investment approvals in France, Britain and the United States, and clearance by the Commission under the EU’s foreign-subsidies rules. Avio closed on Wednesday at EUR 39.50, below the offer, by Milano Finanza’s figure. Rafal Modrzewski, ICEYE’s chief executive, aims to close in the first quarter of 2027, which Intermonte’s analysts call highly unrealistic. Mediobanca’s analysts, who put the offer 7 per cent below their EUR 44 target price and call Avio a strategic supplier of MBDA, say full government approval cannot be taken for granted. Joint-venture partners, BAE Systems and Airbus among them, may be unfavourable to a change of owner, they say. They also see Leonardo keeping a stake in the new company as one alternative.

Signal › Crosetto sits in the government that decides golden power and also controls the seller: the economy ministry holds about 30.2 per cent of Leonardo, which Leonardo’s governance report says leaves the company under its de facto control. Leonardo’s 18.04 per cent blocks nothing on its own, but without it 66.67 per cent of the capital needs tenders from roughly 81 to 84 per cent of the remaining shares, depending on how Avio’s 2.25 per cent of treasury shares is counted. ICEYE may waive that threshold; below 90 per cent it plans to merge Avio into its unlisted bidding company, which needs two thirds of the capital represented at an extraordinary meeting, where Leonardo votes. The notice treats the two US reviews differently. The Pentagon’s Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency need only allow suitable mitigation of foreign ownership to remain in place; CFIUS must approve without conditions or remedial measures, for a company whose US plant is to build motors for US Army missiles. A CFIUS approval subject to mitigation would therefore not satisfy the offer’s condition; ICEYE, which reserves the right to waive any of its conditions, would have to decide whether to waive it.

INTDINSTK EU defence ministers endorse eight joint-project opportunities, a cruise-missile family and space early warning among them

European Defence Agency 17 Nov

At the European Defence Agency’s Steering Board on Tuesday, EU defence ministers approved the 2026 Coordinated Annual Review on Defence and endorsed eight collaborative opportunities: a family of cruise missiles; long-range rocket artillery; unmanned ground vehicles; layered counter-drone defence for critical infrastructure and deployed forces; a family of long-range air defence interceptors; space-based early warning, detection and tracking; a European secure defence cloud; and strategic air mobility. The review asks member states to consider cooperation in their national programmes and budgets; the endorsement commits no state to a programme. Ministers also endorsed a statement on security of supply and raised the agency’s 2027 budget by 8.7 per cent to EUR 78 million.

SPCIAMDDEZDIN Germany nears a deal with Airbus and OHB for two missile-warning satellites in geostationary orbit, hartpunkt reports

hartpunkt 17 Nov · French Ministry of the Armed Forces 24 Oct 2025 · DoD News 13 Dec 2018 · 14 Aug 2019 · Signal No. 187

Germany’s talks with Airbus Defence and Space, with OHB as subcontractor, on two geostationary infrared satellites for Satellite Based Missile Detection (SBMD) are largely concluded, hartpunkt reported on Tuesday, citing well-informed circles; a submission to the Bundestag is planned for December. Neither Airbus nor the ministry has commented. Infrared satellites of this kind are designed to detect the hot exhaust of a ballistic missile, especially in its boost phase. Because satellites are usually procured under operator contracts, the money sits in the budget line for complex services in space, hartpunkt notes; the finance ministry’s amended draft raised that line’s commitment authority to just over EUR 10 billion. hartpunkt puts a first capability at 2029 or 2030, its own estimate based on a build time of three to four years, and reports that the ministry is planning a constellation in low orbit for missile detection, and has begun first market research.

hartpunkt places SBMD in Germany’s cooperation with France. Under the JEWEL letter of intent of 15 October 2025, France and Germany are each to launch one or two interoperable geostationary satellites that watch continuously for missile launches, for a first European capability in the early 2030s; until then, the French ministry says, Europe depends on US early-warning data.

Signal › The planned procurement buys launch warning, not tracking. A geostationary pair can detect the boost phase of ballistic missiles such as Russia’s Iskander-M and Oreshnik, giving Germany an early-warning capability of its own rather than relying solely on US data. It is not the tracking layer required to follow a hypersonic glider. In December 2018 Michael Griffin, then the Pentagon’s research chief, put hypersonic targets at 10 to 20 times dimmer than what US geostationary satellites normally track; in August 2019 he said “we can’t see these things from a few spacecraft in geostationary orbit”, and called for a proliferated sensor layer in much lower orbit, the layer Signal No. 187 measured Germany’s new space money against.

Procurement · Industry · Capability

IAMDDINDEZ ZF is to build Hensoldt’s Spexer counter-drone radars in series

Hensoldt and ZF Friedrichshafen signed a cooperation agreement at the federal economy ministry on Wednesday under which ZF will set up a scalable series-production facility for Spexer radars, with an automated test system, and deliver them directly to customers; Hensoldt retains the intellectual property. The Spexer 2000 is the radar in Rheinmetall’s Skyranger 30, which the Bundeswehr is buying for short- and very-short-range air defence. No value, capacity or site was given.

Hensoldt 18 Nov

SPCSTKDIN MBDA Deutschland and ATMOS agree to study military payloads carried in orbit

MBDA Deutschland and ATMOS Space Cargo, a German maker of re-entry capsules, signed a cooperation agreement on Wednesday to design, develop and demonstrate what they call Precision Orbital Deep Strike: an orbital transfer and return vehicle derived from ATMOS’s Phoenix capsule, staying in orbit for months, with the military payload and guidance from MBDA. The first steps cover architecture, feasibility, payload integration and possible demonstrations; development would need separate agreements. No customer is named. The Outer Space Treaty bars only nuclear weapons and other weapons of mass destruction from orbit.

hartpunkt 18 Nov · OPEX360 18 Nov

SPCDIN OHB’s launch-site company is to assess Ireland’s west coast for a spaceport

OHB and SUAS Aerospace, an Irish spaceport developer, signed an agreement at Space Tech Expo Europe in Bremen on Wednesday under which TESC, OHB’s launch-infrastructure subsidiary, will evaluate sites on Ireland’s west coast for future launch operations and define the technical and operational requirements. OHB calls it a next phase of earlier work with SUAS. No site, value or schedule was given.

OHB 18 Nov

AIRRUCIAMD Kyiv says France will deliver two more Mirage 2000-5F and a Ground Fire 300 radar by year-end

Ukraine’s defence ministry said after Tuesday’s Contact Group that France will deliver by the end of 2026 two more Mirage 2000-5F fighters with ammunition, including 30 mm cannon rounds bought through an EU loan, and a Thales Ground Fire 300 radar, which can track ballistic missiles. Norway and Germany are funding deliveries of AASM Hammer 250 guided bombs.

Militarnyi 18 Nov

UXSDINDEZ Airbus and Aeronautics plan to build the Orbiter 4 VTOL drone in Germany

Airbus Defence and Space Airborne Solutions and Israel’s Aeronautics announced a teaming agreement on Tuesday to set up production and assembly of the Orbiter 4 VTOL in Germany, with technology transfer and adaptation to German requirements. By the maker’s figures the drone weighs up to 55 kg at take-off and flies for more than 24 hours. No Bundeswehr requirement, quantity or value was named.

hartpunkt 18 Nov

Forward Look

This week. Thursday 19 November: Coalition of the Willing leaders meet in Berlin, chaired by Germany, Britain and France (Ukrinform 3 Nov); US envoys, Ukrainian officials and European allies are to meet in Berlin this week (Kyiv Independent 17 Nov); Trump, Xi and Putin meet in Shenzhen at APEC (CNBC 18 Nov); the German army stands up eight battalions at Munster, among them units of Panzerbrigade 45 (German Army 12 Nov); the Folketing’s final vote on the Greenland agreement (Ritzau 22 Oct). Friday: Estonia’s government discusses closing its land crossings with Russia from 1 December (ERR 18 Nov).

Later. 24–27 November: the Bundestag’s second and third readings of the 2027 budget, with the Bundesrat on 18 December (defence-network 13 Nov). 26–27 November: the European Council, where von der Leyen presents the EUR 45 billion proposal (Ukrinform 18 Nov), and Rheinmetall’s capital markets day (dpa-AFX 5 Nov). First days of December: the US Europe Posture Review reaches the White House, by Warsaw’s account (Defence24 17 Nov). 12 January: the Seimas’s final vote on deleting Article 137 (BNS via LRT 6 Oct).

Exercises. No changes since Monday. Full calendar: Großwald NATO Exercises 2026.

Großwald profile image
by Großwald

Subscribe to Signal.

Your daily briefing on procurement, force posture, industrial capacity and the alliance. Every weekday, 23:00 CET.

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More